Hi Perry,
Perry wrote
1. Should the seal be on the lifting part of the hatch, and shut down on to the main fixed lp, or the other way round,
The standard boat doesn't have any seal on the forehatch, so what you have has been retro-fitted by a previous owner.
The hatch should have a lip all around that matches the height of the upstand all around the edge of the hole in the foredeck. The hatch should therefore neatly wrap over the hole - and that's it!
Obviously, due to manufacturing tolerances with GRP laid-up by hand, there's plenty room for gaps around the edge, but mine has never let rain in. Being a Broads sailor I can't say I've experienced waves over the bow sufficient to make it's way into the cabin, so I have never bothered to seal my hatch and it leaves your second question redundant.
Tell me more about your problems. Could the seal itself be drawing water over the hatch lip by capillary action, syphoning or osmosis?